PULLMAN INQUEST

from The Record, Sodus, N.Y. -  April 13, 1906

The inquest in the case of Edward Pullman, the murdered constable and night watchman, was called in the Sodus Opera House Friday forenoon by Coroner Robert S. Carr.
The first witness sworn was William Dickinson, who resides seven miles east of West Webster. He told of his horse being stolen the morning of March 23d, and of the leaving of another horse in its place. He heard nothing during the night. At the time the animal was stolen it was shedding hair. Horse hairs were found on the men who were arrested in Rochester as suspects, so this part of Mr. Dickinson's testimony was considered important. Lorenzo Atwater of Webster testified as to having found Mr. Dickinson's horse and returning the same to the barn.
M. F. Boyd was called for at this stage of the proceedings, but he was absent.
Edward C. Smith of Webster took the stand. He said he discovered the morning of the 23d that someone had been swapping horses with him. He found the doors of his barn open, and discovered a strange horse in place of his animal. His wife telephoned to Webster and later to chief of police at Rochester of the fact. Afterwards he procured his horse and the cutter to which the animal was hitched in Rochester. Drove horse home and shipped cutter to M. F. Boyd at Sodus.
Mr. Boyd reached the Opera House by this time and testified that a horse was stolen from his barn the night of the 23d. He was not able to tell if horse was driven out of barn, after being hitched to cutter. Horse was in fair condition when returned.
Dr. J. F. Myers took the stand and swore that he made an autopsy on the body of Edward Pullman the morning of March 23d. He first saw the body at 6:30 a. m., as it lay on the floor in the bank and store. He examined the body at that time. There was no blood on the floor, or any to be observed externally on the body. Clothing did nor, have the appearance of having been disarranged. He discovered that a pistol ball had been fired through a side window and lodged in a book case.
William R. Shonassy, a conductor on the R. W. & 0. R. R., arrived at this time, and he was immediately called to the stand. He testified that he left Rochester at 5:40 p. m. March 22d and arrived at Sodus about eleven minutes late. He identified a train slip issued by him to a man who paid a cash fare from Rochester to Wallington, but who got off the train at Sodus. He swore that another man who had paid him a cash fare from Rochester to Wolcott also got off the train at Sodus. Neither passenger asked for rebate fare. The man for Wolcott sat directly behind the man for Wallington. They did not converse with each other.

After the conductor left the stand Dr. Myers resumed his testimony, swearing as to the location of the bullet wounds that caused the death of the night watchman. He told of the removal of the body to the undertaking rooms of J. J. Wylie and the examination which showed no bruises other than those inflicted by the bullet, which he believed came from a 38 revolver.
Captain George Garlock of Sodus Point stated that on March 22d he was visited by a stranger who attracted his attention. The fellow acted strangely. Mr. Garlock said he thought he would be able to recognize the man if he saw him again. He then swore that he did see the man in question on Monday, April 2d, at the sheriff's office in Lyons. He thought the man was Schultz. The man wore dark clothes, overcoat and derby hat.
C. K. Knapp testified to having been notified of the crime and of his immediate visit to the bank, finding the front door' locked and of his being unable to turn the same by the use of his key. After trying for several minutes to open it in this manner, Albert Hamm went to the rear of the building and found the door closed, but not fastened. He made his way into the store and unbolted the front door from the top. The finding of the bullet holes, the hole drilled in the safe and other matters known to the public were brought out in Mr. Knapp's testimony.
Mrs. W. W. Wood was called. She swore that she was disturbed the morning of the 23d and looked out of the window. She saw a man come across the cross walk. He stopped and stood still. Then she saw two shots fired and saw the flash. After, that she heard a scuffling noise. She heard no shots after that. Later a door was slammed. Then she saw three men go west, past Cornelius' store. She watched them until they reached the home of Mrs. A. B. Williams. Soon afterwards two men went west on the south side of Main street. There was one short and one tall men on the north side. They walked rapidly. It was 1:45 a. m. at that time.
Owen Wood testified that he was awakened by four reports which sounded like fire crackers being exploded. He got up and look out of the window and saw a man standing in front of Gardner's store. Another shot was heard and the man immediately disappeared from sight. After this he dropped the curtain and went back to bed.
C. C. Field then gave his testimony in which he told of the finding of the constable's body, after he had been called from his bed by Miss Pulman, who informed him that the family members were fearful that something had happened to Mr. Pullman. After Mr. Field's testimony was concluded the inquest was adjourned until Wednesday, April 11th. It was announced that the three prisioners at the county jail would be brought to Sodus at that time.

The report of Wednesday's developments will be found on page 5.

Return to Pullman Index

Return to History Index

Return to Main Index